Ibiza or Mallorca: which Balearic Island should you visit?

The Balearic Islands, off the eastern shores of Spain, are regularly in the top spots of lists for the best Mediterranean island escapes. Whether you are looking to spend the day lazily on a golden sandy stretch, up for dancing the night away under the stars or simply just after quality time with your love ones, there’s a Balearic Island out there for you!

The two titans of the Balearics are undoubtedly Ibiza and Mallorca, each offering a distinct experience and aiming to steal your heart. But, which one is actually the better island? To help you decide whether your should visit Ibiza or Mallorca, we’ve compared the two islands.

• Beaches
• Nightlife
• Sights & outdoors
• Family friendly
• Best off-season escape
• Top tips

The Battle of the Balearic Beaches!

Ibiza

If there’s one thing Ibiza knows, it is how to dazzle with its beaches: think hidden rocky coves, long stretches of sand, and sunsets pulled straight out of a painting. Cala Comte and Benirrás serve up front-row seats to jaw-dropping dusk views, while Las Salinas is the go-to for beach parties and stylish lounging.

After for something a bit more peaceful? Then head over to Sol d'en Serra and Cala d’Hort, for that winning combination of cliffside charm and dreamy waters. Similarly, Cala Xarraca and Aigua Blanca have a relaxed, naturist vibe that is perfect for snorkeling. As for family-friendly beaches, Ibiza has you covered with the shallow and welcoming waters of Talamanca being just minutes from Ibiza Town.

Mallorca

The beaches of Mallorca are truly out of this world. With long golden shores and secret calas tucked between cliffs, the island is a playground for beach lovers. Es Trenc steals the show with untouched beauty and calm, shallow waters, while Cala Mondragó and S’Amarador in the Mondragó National Park will steal your heart with their soft sand, turquoise seas, and just the right amount of amenities.

If you are after that rugged Balearic charm, then head to Cala Pi or Cabo de Formentor for the dramatic landscapes and pine-fringed serenity. And if you are looking for something wilder with a splash of hippie freedom, Cala Varques is totally off-grid. Just bring snacks, good vibes, and prepare to fall in love with going to the beach all over again.

Our pick: Mallorca

While Ibiza has its fair share of sandy stretches, Mallorca comes on top with its sheer variety and number of options when it comes to beaches. On top of that, the thinner crowds and abundance of secluded coves make it easier to enjoy a relaxing day out on the beach.

Let the good times roll at Es Trenc!

Nightlife showdown

Ibiza

The nightlife in Ibiza is nothing short of legendary; with world-class clubs and beach bars attracting DJs from all over the world to spin the decks, you are (almost) guaranteed a good time out the minute you set foot on Ibiza. That said, Ibiza isn’t just about dancing away to staccato beats all night long, there’s also room for laid-back sunset sessions, swanky beach lounges, and iconic venues that have become nightlife institutions. 

Start the night at Café del Mar in San Antonio, where chill-out music and golden-hour views set the mood. Then crank it up a notch and head to clubs like Ushuaïa and Bora Bora in Playa d’en Bossa, or the legendary Amnesia near San Rafel. For a more upscale vibe, Blue Marlin Ibiza in Cala Jondal is a must. The best part? The Discobus runs all night, connecting major clubs with a party-on-wheels feel.

Mallorca

Although Ibiza’s nightlife deservedly claims the spotlight, it doesn’t mean that the other islands are a slouch. In fact, as the largest island in the Balearics, Mallorca may play it cool, but its nightlife has plenty of spark. Palma is the epicenter of after-dark fun, with buzzing cocktail bars and dance spots tucked between La Llonja, Santa Catalina, and the Old Town. 

Think rooftop drinks, open-air terraces, and everything from live jazz to house beats. When summer hits, things really heat up in beach towns like Magaluf, S’Arenal, and Alcúdia, which go full throttle with beach parties and all-night dancing. Whether you're up for a night of pub-hopping or want to let loose on a beachfront dancefloor, Mallorca brings the energy, minus the chaos.

Our pick: Ibiza

In a decision that will shock no one, we feel that Ibiza has the edge on Mallorca when it comes to nightlife. And who could really argue otherwise? Year after year, Ibiza’s bars and nightclubs are packed, so they must be doing something right. That said, it doesn’t mean that you aren’t going to have a great time out at night in Palma, far from it; Mallorca has its own clubbing scene, only a little bit tamer and relaxed.

Ibiza truly comes alive after the sun sets

What about the sights and outdoors?

Ibiza

Ibiza is mostly known for its clubbing scene, but it also has its more traditional side. Case in point, the villages of Ibiza, like Es Cubells or Sant Agustí, where whitewashed houses and quiet charm take center stage. In Ibiza Town, wander the UNESCO-listed Dalt Vila, climb up cobbled alleys to panoramic viewpoints, and explore museums like the Puig des Molins necropolis. 

For something more mystical, Es Vedrà offers a dose of myth and jaw-dropping scenery, whether you hike to a viewpoint or hop on a boat tour. Nature lovers can lose themselves in the salt flats of Ses Salines, the Can Marçà cave system, or the rugged northern trails. For a splash of modern culture, the island’s contemporary art museum (MACE) is a must.

Mallorca

There’s quite a lot to see and do in Palma, from the magnificent cathedral of La Seu to the 14th-century Bellver Castle and the lively Es Baluard art museum. But Mallorca doesn’t stop there. Step beyond the city to find medieval Alcúdia, artsy Pollença, and fairytale Valldemossa nestled in the Tramuntana mountains. The island’s caves are another highlight—Cuevas del Drach even comes with a boat ride and classical concert on Lake Martel. 

If you’re into nature, the S’Albufera reserve is a birdwatcher’s paradise, and the lighthouse at Formentor offers one of the most epic lookouts in the Balearics. Outdoor lovers can hike, cycle, coasteer, or ride horseback through pine-scented trails, while culture seekers will love the Joan Miró museum and the laid-back charm of Fornalutx or Deià.

Pro tip: check out our Palma-Sóller train guide for a fun day exploring Mallorca’s capital city.

Our pick: tied!

Both islands have some of the best hiking trails in the Balearics, and if you want to get closer to nature, there are plenty of options for camping in Mallorca and Ibiza. Whether it’s sea views, street markets, or secret coves, Ibiza’s outdoors hits a different kind of high. Likewise, Mallorca is an island of many moods, and each one is worth exploring. Wherever you decide to go, you will be amazed by how much you will discover as soon as you scratch the surface.

You are bound to find amazing views around every corner

Which island is the most family-friendly?

Ibiza

Although Ibiza is generally thought of an epic party destination, it is also surprisingly a great choice for a family vacation, especially if you know where to go. Many of Ibiza’s resorts offer family-friendly amenities like kids’ clubs, pools and entertainment. 

Leaving behind the booming nightlife of Playa d’en Bossa for the calmer beaches of Santa Eulalia or Portinatx in the north, you will discover the quieter, more relaxed side of the island. Curious little explorers will love visiting the Aquarium Cap Blanc (set inside a cave!), or taking boat trips to see dolphins and the mythical island of Es Vedrà. And for a low-key, post-swim afternoon with the entire family, Ibiza’s hippy markets are a sensory treat for kids and adults alike.

Mallorca

Mallorca is one of the most family-friendly islands in the Mediterranean, full stop. Offering a great mix of comfort, convenience, and fun, traveling with kids has never been easier. The bay of Alcúdia is a top pick for families, thanks to its long sandy beach, gentle waters and wide range of hotels, restaurants, and child-friendly attractions. 

But the fun doesn’t end there, as there are water parks, mini-golf courses, aquariums, and even horseback riding opportunities for the more adventurous. If you are into exploring Mallorca’s outdoors, the natural park of S’Albufera is perfect for wildlife-spotting and scenic walks with the entire family. Palma also has its share of family-friendly museums and cultural sights, and the island’s excellent road network means day trips are a breeze.

Tip: you can check out our 7-day family holiday in Mallorca for more inspiration and ideas.

Our pick: Mallorca

With short travel distances, great child-friendly facilities, and plenty of beaches to enjoy the sunshine, Ibiza proves it’s more than just the island that never sleeps, it’s one where families can truly unwind. On the other hand, Mallorca comes on top thanks to more options and a relaxed atmosphere. Whether you’re taking the family to explore a pirate cave, hop aboard a vintage train, or just want to enjoy a lazy beach day, Mallorca keeps everyone happy, from toddlers to teens (and parents too).

All aboard the tram to Sóller in Mallorca!

Best off-season escape

Ibiza

Visiting Ibiza in autumn is, quite simply, an amazing opportunity to experience the island in a new light. As the summer crowds fade, the island shifts gears into a slower, softer rhythm that feels like a well-kept secret. The weather in September and October is still warm and sunny, with sea temperatures perfect for a final swim. 

You’ll find emptier beaches, quieter streets and deeply discounted accommodation, which is ideal if you're after a spontaneous escape or a budget-friendly break. Autumn is also when Ibiza’s cultural calendar picks up: you can expect local festivals, harvest fairs and art events, all with a relaxed island vibe. As for the outdoors during this season, the hiking trails in the north are lush and tranquil, and sunsets become even more breathtaking without the summer haze.

Mallorca

As a more laid-back destination, it will come as no surprise that Mallorca shines during winter. With mild temperatures, peaceful towns, and crisp mountain air, it’s a dream for those who prefer their holidays quiet and authentic. While the beach scene slows down, Mallorca’s hiking and cycling trails come alive. 

The Serra de Tramuntana is especially popular with winter adventurers. In Palma, you can explore the Gothic cathedral, sip coffee in sun-drenched squares and browse local markets, all without jostling for space. Winter is also almond blossom season and come February, the island is blanketed in delicate white and pink flowers, making for some truly magical drives and walks.

Our pick: tied!

There are many great things to do in the Balearic Islands in the off-season, with Ibiza and Mallorca offering their own kind of magic. Ibiza seduces with its golden autumn light, uncrowded coves and laid-back village life, while Mallorca’s winter charm lies in its scenic trails, peaceful towns and local festivals. Each island offers a quieter, more intimate version of itself when the summer crowds disappear, so it comes down to whether you’re chasing sunsets or almond blossoms.

Don’t forget: for an even greater, more authentic experience, you can combine your visit to Ibiza or Mallorca with some off-season island-hopping in the Balearics.

The Balearic Islands will astound you any time of the year

Top tips

Here are some tips to help you better plan your trip to Ibiza or Mallorca

• Both Ibiza and Mallorca are great bases for island-hopping in the Balearics during the summer. To plan your sea-borne adventure, you can check out our guide to island-hopping from Ibiza and the Balearic Islands ferry schedules.
• For a more authentic slice of life on the islands, don’t forget that the lesser-known Balearic Islands are a short hop from Mallorca, Ibiza, and Formentera.
• If you’re a food lover, don’t miss out on the local gastronomy on both islands! Check out our Balearic Island foodie guide to discover some of the best dishes to try and where to find them.
  Renting a car or scooter is one of the best ways to explore the hidden beaches, charming villages, and scenic spots that lie beyond the main resorts, especially in the off-season when public transport is limited.

So, should you visit Ibiza or Mallorca?

With so much to see, taste, and explore, choosing between Ibiza and Mallorca can be a tough call, but that’s half the fun! It all comes down to what kind of island experience you are after:

• Want to party? Ibiza is the place to be.
• Love road trips and nature? Mallorca won’t disappoint.
• Longing for a day on the beach? Can’t go wrong with Ibiza or Mallorca.
• Traveling with kids and family? Mallorca is your best bet.
• Want a bit of everything or an off-season escape? Maybe both! 😉

Wondering if you can visit both Ibiza and Mallorca? Well, the answer is a resounding yes! In fact, the Ibiza-Mallorca and Mallorca-Ibiza ferry routes usually run twice a day from April to October, so planning a day trip (or full-on adventure) to determine which is the better island is a piece of cake!

Wherever you decide to go, keep in mind that you can always book cheap ferry tickets on Ferryhopper, to the Balearic Islands and beyond, with no hidden fees!